- STR Daily
- Posts
- 12 Best STR Finds | April 27, 2025
12 Best STR Finds | April 27, 2025
The Market's Top Short Term Rentals – Yours Before Anyone Else.
May 11, 2025 | Issue # 168 |
STR DAILY
Hey, friend! Today’s properties include properties in Florida, Georgia, and New York all showing greater than 24% cash-on-cash returns. These and more inside.
Could one of these be your next income-producing gem? Let’s make this the year you get the property that changes your life. Enjoy and good luck!

Before we get to today’s listings – if you’re serious about your search, let us help you. Upgrade to receive personalized listings to your email inbox daily.
Looking for new listings under $200K?
Want to find listings only in the Hudson Valley?
Properties can’t be more than $30K out of pocket?
Need something that’s going to deliver 20%+ CoC return?
We’ve got you covered.
For $30/mo. you’ll get an ongoing listings database of the best daily listings that meet your exact needs. Additionally, you’ll receive:
The ‘Investment Analysis’ tool I use to evaluate my investment opportunities.
The ‘Monthly Revenue Tracker’ I use to manage my Airbnb P&L.
The ‘Mortgage Payoff & Amortization Schedule’ I use to monitor may pay down rate and property equity.
We’ll help you find your perfect property or your money back. Let’s make this the year you get the property that changes your life. Sign up below 👇
TODAY’S TOP PROPERTIES

Here’s what I love about it – Flip Flop Stop flips the script on vacation rentals—two turnkey abodes (a 3-bed main house plus a detached 1-bed pool house) deliver ultimate flex and privacy under one tropical roof. A heated pool fringed by lush palms, Edison-lit wet bar, and air hockey–meets–pool-table game room turn every stay into a Gulf-side carnival. Minutes from Pier Park and St. Andrews State Park, this fully furnished showstopper grossed $115K in 2023, $131K in 2024, and is already $106K strong in 2025. With bookings forecast at $99.9K, $48K annual cash flow, and a sun-sational 28.7% cash-on-cash return, the numbers sparkle brighter than a beach sunset. Flip flops? Mandatory; ROI? Non-negotiable.
Price: $625,000
BR/Bath: 4 Bedroom / 3 Bath
Sq. Feet: 2,383
Avg. Daily Rate: $519
Expected Occupancy Rate: 53%
Expected Annual Revenue: $99,870
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $48,170
Expected Cash on Cash: 28.74%

Here’s what I love about it – Pastoral paradise on 3.92 acres: wrap-around deck and serene pond deliver Catskill sunsets? Included, no filter needed. Inside, a primary suite channels spa-day vibes while a secondary ensuite plus two more bedrooms keep guests grinning. Gourmet kitchen and wood-burning fireplace marry modern convenience with cozy charm—perfect for epic holiday gatherings. Finished basement gym/office combo and a second level pre-plumbed for expansion mean bonus suites or that Airbnb annex you’ve been dreaming of. With projected cash flow north of $66.8K and a 29.6% cash-on-cash return, this Catskill charmer combines mountain magic with money moves.
Price: $895,000
BR/Bath: 5 Bedroom / 4 Bath
Sq. Feet: 2,000
Avg. Daily Rate: $693
Expected Occupancy Rate: 56%
Expected Annual Revenue: $140,568
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $66,852
Expected Cash on Cash: 29.60%

Here’s what I love about it – Pagosa Springs sprawls across 37 private acres—vaulted ceilings, a chef’s island, and a seasonal pond set the stage for Southwest Colorado serenity. Bedrooms at opposite ends guarantee gossip-free getaways, while the wraparound porch and fire pit double as elk-viewing VIP decks. Private gate access to National Forest & BLM lands means trailblazing on demand. Fully furnished, low-tax thanks to community grazing, and road-maintained for year-round ease—this modern ranch screams “turnkey.” Projected bookings hit $84K (10.4% gross yield), proving that peace and profit can share the same zip code.
Price: $805,000
BR/Bath: 2 Bedroom / 2 Bath
Sq. Feet: 1,494
Avg. Daily Rate: $318
Expected Occupancy Rate: 72%
Expected Annual Revenue: $84,032
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $23,241
Expected Cash on Cash: 11.62%

Here’s what I love about it – Tudor treasure in Berkshire Green—hardwood floors, formal dining, and a game room that begs foosball marathons. Move-in-ready kitchen, first-floor master suite, and fresh paint? Turnkey trifecta. Backyard bliss comes courtesy of an above-ground pool and a shed prepped for your paddleboard stash. Projected cash flow of $12.8K and a cash-on-cash return of 15.5% prove this gem pays its own way. Classic charm, modern income—now that’s a storybook ending.
Price: $279,900
BR/Bath: 4 Bedroom / 2 Bath
Sq. Feet: 1,847
Avg. Daily Rate: $191
Expected Occupancy Rate: 50%
Expected Annual Revenue: $34,688
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $12,840
Expected Cash on Cash: 15.50%

Here’s what I love about it – Rustic retreat vibes meet Lake Superior serenity—vaulted ceilings, hardwood floors, and a cozy fireplace set the tone for forest-framed living. An enclosed patio blurs indoor comfort with woodland zen, while community beach access to the Big Lake? Included, no filter needed. At 954 sq ft, this 1-bed gem delivers projected bookings of $33K a year—your ticket to Superior sunsets and solid yield. Lake Superior envy guaranteed.
Price: $350,000
BR/Bath: 1 Bedroom / 1 Bath
Sq. Feet: 954
Avg. Daily Rate: $209
Expected Occupancy Rate: 43%
Expected Annual Revenue: $33,177
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $7,183
Expected Cash on Cash: 7.98%

Here’s what I love about it – STR-ready “Fireside Chats” cabin sprawls across 1.22 wooded acres in Sunrise Ridge East, just minutes from Beavers Bend State Park and Broken Bow Lake. Vaulted ceilings, floor-to-ceiling windows, and a stone fireplace set the scene for rustic tales, while the chef’s kitchen and coffee bar keep mornings—and meals—memorable. Two luxe suites with soaker tubs and an arcade-ready loft complete with Murphy beds and sunset balcony bring unexpected flair. Outside, cornhole, a back-deck fireplace, and a hot tub under the stars keep those “fireside chats” literal. With projected bookings of $69.3K and gross yields north of 9%, this cabin proves the best conversations happen where the trees are tall and the returns taller.
Price: $749,000
BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 3 Bath
Sq. Feet: 1,969
Avg. Daily Rate: $423
Expected Occupancy Rate: 45%
Expected Annual Revenue: $69,322
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $13,912
Expected Cash on Cash: 7.25%

Here’s what I love about it – Privacy on 2.33 acres with a sun deck–jacuzzi and stock-tank pool? Desert spa vibes unlocked. Concrete floors and skylit ceilings fuse mid-century cool with open-concept flow and a brick fireplace perfect for star-lit lounging. Primary suite’s soaking tub and walk-in shower deliver spa-day feels, while two guest bedrooms keep the crowd happy. Projected bookings hit $97.5K, with $35.5K cash flow and a 17% cash-on-cash return—money magic in the Mojave. In Joshua Tree, stargazing’s great—but returns shine even brighter.
Price: $797,000
BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 3 Bath
Sq. Feet: 2,335
Avg. Daily Rate: $424
Expected Occupancy Rate: 63%
Expected Annual Revenue: $97,501
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $35,454
Expected Cash on Cash: 17.16%

Here’s what I love about it – Sun-splashed five-bedroom, five-bath on Panama City Beach’s west end feels like a permanent vacation, courtesy of Holland Homes’ Rosemary floor plan. Open-concept living and a center-island kitchen flow seamlessly onto a covered back porch primed for sunset soirées. Upstairs, a balcony-bound primary suite and bonus rooms stand ready for sleepy mornings or après-beach fiestas. Projected revenue of $136.9K, cash flow of $64.6K, and a nearly 29% cash-on-cash return prove this beachside beauty isn’t just a getaway—it’s a Gulf-coast goldmine. Sand between your toes. Cash in your pocket.
Price: $879,850
BR/Bath: 5 Bedroom / 5 Bath
Sq. Feet: 2,233
Avg. Daily Rate: $737
Expected Occupancy Rate: 51%
Expected Annual Revenue: $136,930
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $64,625
Expected Cash on Cash: 28.76%

Here’s what I love about it – Spectacular sunsets? Check. Three levels of 5-star fun—65″ TV binge sessions, pool-table smackdowns, and an ADA-friendly parking spot (everyone’s VIP here). Blazing 466 Mbps Wi-Fi and a firepit beckon cozy nights under the stars. Fully furnished and locked into an active STR program, it’s already pulling in projected bookings of $52.5K. In the mountains, the only thing cooler than evening air is this cabin’s income potential.
Price: $549,000
BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 3 Bath
Sq. Feet: 2,356
Avg. Daily Rate: $211
Expected Occupancy Rate: 68%
Expected Annual Revenue: $52,483
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $11,651
Expected Cash on Cash: 7.78%

Here’s what I love about it - Historic soul meets modern swagger in Manteo’s downtown heart—this 3-bed, 2-bath beauty marries clapboard charm with mini-split mojo and a clawfoot-tub bubble fest. Fresh floors and a wood-ceilinged living room dish front-porch vibes that whisper “sweet tea o’clock.” A fenced yard and revamped shed double as your studio—or storage? You decide. Raking in $47.9K annually with $17.5K cash flow and a 17.7% cash-on-cash return, this Outer Banks gem proves nostalgia pays. Porch cred and Roanoke Sound breezes? Always on tap.
Price: $389,000
BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 2 Bath
Sq. Feet: 980
Avg. Daily Rate: $262
Expected Occupancy Rate: 50%
Expected Annual Revenue: $47,862
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $17,543
Expected Cash on Cash: 17.67%

Here’s what I love about it – Lake June Cove’s lakefront luxe meets multi-guest magic—3 beds in the main house plus a full garage-top apartment, all under tongue-and-groove beamed ceilings. Glide out on your private boathouse lift or gather under the gazebo with 100 ft of waterfront as the main event. Screened porches and a sprawling deck turn sunset soirees into daily rituals, while two laundry rooms and an outdoor shed deliver a linen-duty trifecta. Projected bookings cruise to $89K, cash flow pops at $34K, and cash-on-cash nudges nearly 18%—sunshine returns without the sandy shoes. Just two hours from South Florida, Orlando, or Tampa, this retreat anchors serene lake living and savvy ROI in one rare slice of Cove life.
Price: $698,750
BR/Bath: 4 Bedroom / 4 Bath
Sq. Feet: 3,008
Avg. Daily Rate: $450
Expected Occupancy Rate: 54%
Expected Annual Revenue: $89,166
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $34,289
Expected Cash on Cash: 17.97%

Here's what I love about it - Four beds, 1.5 baths, and an address that’s minutes from downtown buzz and airport runways (late-night arrivals? Sorted). A seven-year-young roof keeps surprises out, while the huge fenced yard doubles as pup paradise and al fresco hangout. Fully furnished and tried-and-true as an Airbnb, it’s ready for guests the moment you hand over the keys. With nearly $16.9K in annual cash flow and a 24.9% cash-on-cash return, this gem turns convenience into coin faster than baggage claim.
Price: $235,000
BR/Bath: 4 Bedroom / 2 Bath
Sq. Feet: 1,375
Avg. Daily Rate: $185
Expected Occupancy Rate: 53%
Expected Annual Revenue: $36,102
Expected Annual Cash Flow: $16,851
Expected Cash on Cash: 24.85%
Do you follow STR Daily on Instagram? Check out the latest post and give a follow on IG for exclusive content and giveaways:
Buying a short term rental doesn’t need to be complicated. But, with more than 14,000 listings hitting the market every single day, the likelihood of you finding the right home at the right time feels damn near impossible.
You need to find the right location.
With the right unit economics.
And, the right style.
It’s tough.
But, when you do… it’s a game life changer.
The last Airbnb I purchased provides a 16.99% Cash on Cash return with $15,700+ in annual free cash flow after my mortgage and all expenses…
I hope this is a resource that saves you time, so you can make decisions in minutes and avoid missing out on the property that will change your life.
Disclaimer: The information provided on STR Daily is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Short-term rental regulations change constantly, so please review local rules and regulations prior to any purchases. Projected cash-on-cash returns are based on a 20% down payment, estimated furnishing costs appropriate for the property size, and anticipated fees. Actual returns may vary. Please run the numbers yourself or consult a financial professional to assess risks and develop a strategy suited to your specific needs.