• STR Daily
  • Posts
  • 12 Best STR Finds | May 4, 2025

12 Best STR Finds | May 4, 2025

The Market's Top Short Term Rentals – Yours Before Anyone Else.

May 10, 2025

Issue # 174

STR DAILY

Hey, friend! Today’s properties include a 5.5‑acre mountainside haven in Colorado, a Palm Springs beauty with projected bookings of $117K, and a turnkey cottage in the Catskills.

Could one of these be your next income-producing gem? Let’s make this the year you get the property that changes your life. Enjoy and good luck!

Before we get to today’s listings – if you’re serious about your search, let us help you. Upgrade to receive personalized listings to your email inbox daily.

Looking for new listings under $200K?
Want to find listings only in the Hudson Valley?
Properties can’t be more than $30K out of pocket?
Need something that’s going to deliver 20%+ CoC return?

We’ve got you covered.

For $30/mo. you’ll get an ongoing listings database of the best daily listings that meet your exact needs. Additionally, you’ll receive:

  • The ‘Investment Analysis’ tool I use to evaluate my investment opportunities.

  • The ‘Monthly Revenue Tracker’ I use to manage my Airbnb P&L.

  • The ‘Mortgage Payoff & Amortization Schedule’ I use to monitor may pay down rate and property equity.

We’ll help you find your perfect property or your money back. Let’s make this the year you get the property that changes your life. Sign up below 👇

TODAY’S TOP PROPERTIES

Here’s what I love about it – Vaulted ceilings and hardwood floors set the stage for mountain drama, anchored by a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace begging for cozy s’more nights. Three spa-worthy master suites—one per level—plus a lower-level arcade gameroom turn this turnkey cabin into a year-round adventure. Commune with nature outside or flex by the community pool, clubhouse, and gym—cabin fever never felt this good. With projected bookings of $79.8K, $25K cash flow, and 13.7% cash-on-cash, this retreat serves up serenity with a side of serious ROI.

  • Price: $714,900

  • BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 3 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 1,950

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $352

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 62%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $79,844

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $25,179

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 13.69%

Here’s what I love about it – This 5.5‑acre mountainside haven just two minutes from downtown Durango comes with zero HOA, zero covenants, and total freedom to roam. Three ensuite levels—vaulted ceilings, a pellet stove, and a deck made for stargazing—turn multi‑gen living or STR hosting into a cozy off‑grid dream. All‑electric simplicity plus 1 Gig hardwired internet means mountain solitude with marathon‑ready Wi‑Fi. Projected bookings of $86K prove that high‑altitude living can be high‑yield living, too. Game trails by day, cash flow by night—Durango’s wild side just sent you an invite.

  • Price: $865,000

  • BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 3 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 2,512

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $351

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 67%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $86,092

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $21,316

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 9.51%

Here’s what I love about it – Lake-view chapters kick off a hop, skip & paddle from Rocky Branch Park & Marina, with vaulted ceilings and a wood-burning hearth primed for marshmallow roasts. The remodeled kitchen’s cabinet bounty isn’t just eye candy—it’s profit potential. Covered porch and screened deck serve up four-season outdoor vibes, while the workshop garage and truss port say “bring your boat and your DIY dreams.” Projected revenue hits $53.5K, cash flow $18.7K, and 15.8% cash-on-cash return—numbers that float. This cabin doesn’t just retreat—it returns.

  • Price: $450,000

  • BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 2 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 1,536

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $299

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 49%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $53,554

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $18,716

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 15.75%

Here’s what I love about it – Architectural cred by Hugh Kaptur’s Desert Dorado series—this Oasis Del Sol charmer flaunts soaring vaulted ceilings, a stacked-stone fireplace, and a mosaic-tiled outdoor shower made for sudsy sunsets. Resort-style pool and spa? Double check. Minutes from Arenas District nightlife and park trails, it’s central-but-quiet. Projected bookings hit $117K, with $43.9K cash flow and a 19% cash-on-cash that’s sunburningly good. Dawn-to-dusk sunshine? Included, no filter needed.

  • Price: $939,000

  • BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 2 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 1,270

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $534

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 60%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $117,359

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $43,934

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 19.21%

Here’s what I love about it – Single-story desert sanctuary in Twentynine Palms, framed by mature Joshua Trees and panoramic front‑and‑back vistas. Circular driveway ushers you into vaulted ceilings, laminate floors, and a remodeled kitchen with a breezy breakfast bar. Your fenced backyard doubles as a private resort with a cowboy pool, built‑in grill, and s’mores‑ready firepit under endless skies. Just minutes from the Marine Base, downtown shops, and Joshua Tree National Park—adventure and amenities in one package. Projected bookings hit $49K with $18K in cash flow and a 16% cash‑on‑cash return—desert dreams that pay back.

  • Price: $399,000

  • BR/Bath: 4 Bedroom / 2 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 1,901

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $362

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 37%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $49,401

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $18,262

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 16.49%

Here’s what I love about it – Just 90 miles from the GWB, Smallwood’s turnkey cottage flirts with waterfall whispers and open-concept ease. Part-shaded deck laughs at rainy days—cocktail consumption? Guaranteed. A fireplace insert and central heat promise year‑round hygge, while lakeside dining and scenic trails do the hosting for you. Fall foliage? Included, no filter needed. With projected bookings of $41.4K and a 10.8% gross yield, this Catskills charmer proves that charm and returns make perfect bedfellows.

  • Price: $384,900

  • BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 2 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 1,090

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $247

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 46%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $41,441

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $12,210

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 12.28%

Here’s what I love about it – Rocking-chair front porch? Porch therapy included. Stained-glass accents and an open living space soak up natural light—Instagram cameo ready. Projected bookings of $69K and $28K in annual cash flow turn this hike-worthy hideaway into a profit powerhouse. Downstairs den, screened-in deck, scenic hiking trails, stocked lakes, and a clubhouse overhead make guests feel like VIP campers. Cash-on-cash returns near 20% prove that woodland wonders can seriously pad your portfolio.

  • Price: $515,000

  • BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 3 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 2,376

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $285

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 66%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $69,089

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $28,205

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 19.83%

Here’s what I love about it – Classic 2-bed, 1.5-bath charm in Fort Worth’s up-and-coming Byers & McCart—where vintage appeal waltzes with modern perks on a snug 1,150 sq ft stage. Backyard festival mode: swing set, dog-run of dreams, a 12×12 slab primed for BBQ soirées, and a 30‑amp hookup begging for camper or EV action. Blocks from TCU’s game‑day roar and the city’s nightlife, so your guests won’t miss a beat. With $18.7K in annual cash flow and a 26.6% cash‑on‑cash return, this Airbnb darling hits both comfort and ROI out of the park. Fort Worth flair? Served up fresh—no cowboy boots required.

  • Price: $255,000

  • BR/Bath: 2 Bedroom / 2 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 1,150

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $176

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 62%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $39,634

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $18,685

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 26.64%

Here’s what I love about it – Heartland hospitality on steroids—this 6,143 sq ft Hutchinson hideaway serves up modern luxe with classic charm on the biggest lot in town (lawn-envy guaranteed). Two living areas, an all-season sun porch, and a full walkout basement apartment whisper “instant Airbnb empire” or multi-family mojo. Retro St. Charles metal cabinets? Flashback flair that guests will Instagram. With projected bookings of $32.7K and an 11.3% gross yield, this entertainer’s dream spins square feet into sweet returns. Four fireplaces? History‑buff hug spots included.

  • Price: $290,000

  • BR/Bath: 3 Bedroom / 4 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 6,143

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $181

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 49%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $32,699

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $10,484

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 8.18%

Here’s what I love about it - Victorian vibes dialed to eleven—step into the 1886 Anawalt House, where original hardwood floors and soaring ceilings are just the opening act. Five bedrooms, four baths, and a sprawling third‑floor salon (23’6”×18’) ignite guest intrigue, while a fireproof‑safe‑stocked basement doubles as a storm‑shelter plot twist. Historic archways and transom‑topped doors? Instant Insta‑bait for design snobs. STR‑permissible zoning plus a gated 26‑space parking lot means hosting is as smooth as vintage crown molding. Projected bookings of $45.6K—history buffs and bank accounts both approved.

  • Price: $425,000

  • BR/Bath: 5 Bedroom / 4 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 3,816

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $269

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 46%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $45,636

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $13,376

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 9.84%

Here’s what I love about it – Mariposa’s charm turned up to 11 in this fully furnished 2‑bed, 1‑bath gem just outside town—oversized bedrooms, all‑season floors, and a kitchen so smooth even the county line feels jealous. Engineered septic and full rewire? Utility bills vanish faster than afternoon tourists. Separate garage, laundry room, and a private garden? Amenity jackpot without the upkeep headache. With projected bookings of $37.2K and a gross yield near 10%, this treasure practically foots its own welcome mat. Yosemite’s front door? Your guests will treat it like VIP access.

  • Price: $375,000

  • BR/Bath: 2 Bedroom / 1 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 1,000

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $222

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 46%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $37,192

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $9,127

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 9.48%

Here's what I love about it - Treehouse vibes meet lakeside lazy days in this red-siding hillside hideaway at Lake Claire—decks galore and a wood‑burning stove primed for marshmallow missions. Sun‑drenched windows and exposed beams channel rustic‑chic, while multi‑level decks and stone terracing turn backyard barbecues into al fresco spectacles. Steps from the water and minutes from Middletown’s shops and trails, convenience and charm collide. With projected bookings of $30.9K, this cottage delivers a 12.35% gross yield—tranquility that sheets its own checks. Nature’s peace? Guaranteed; ROI that floats? Equally so.

  • Price: $249,999

  • BR/Bath: 2 Bedroom / 2 Bath

  • Sq. Feet: 990

  • Avg. Daily Rate: $187

  • Expected Occupancy Rate: 45%

  • Expected Annual Revenue: $30,881

  • Expected Annual Cash Flow: $11,380

  • Expected Cash on Cash: 16.88%

Do you follow STR Daily on Instagram? Check out the latest post and give a follow on IG for exclusive content and giveaways:

Buying a short term rental doesn’t need to be complicated. But, with more than 14,000 listings hitting the market every single day, the likelihood of you finding the right home at the right time feels damn near impossible.

You need to find the right location.
With the right unit economics.
And, the right style.

It’s tough.

But, when you do… it’s a game life changer.

The last Airbnb I purchased provides a 16.99% Cash on Cash return with $15,700+ in annual free cash flow after my mortgage and all expenses…

I hope this is a resource that saves you time, so you can make decisions in minutes and avoid missing out on the property that will change your life.

Disclaimer: The information provided on STR Daily is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Short-term rental regulations change constantly, so please review local rules and regulations prior to any purchases. Projected cash-on-cash returns are based on a 20% down payment, estimated furnishing costs appropriate for the property size, and anticipated fees. Actual returns may vary. Please run the numbers yourself or consult a financial professional to assess risks and develop a strategy suited to your specific needs.